top of page
Writer's pictureTry Bay Area

Sibby's Cupcake Shop in Downtown San Mateo for Custom Cupcakes, Fun Flavors, and More

This is a tiny cupcake shop with big flavors! Located on Railroad Ave in downtown San Mateo facing the Caltrain tracks, it's quite the hidden gem amongst other industrial businesses and not many people probably walk along this street. But you walk in and bam! So colorful and so many sweet treats!



So many flavors and such cute decorations on the cupcakes! They have regular sized cupcakes and mini ones, and apparently also jumbo ones!




Full menu:


Our order:


Ok it got a little smooshed in the box on the ride home but this one was really really good! It's a seasonal limited edition flavor for February. I liked the fresh strawberries in it! And I know they were fresh strawberries because I saw a delivery of fresh fruits arriving at the store when I was there haha!



Choc cupcakes like from our childhood! Also good!



It was a small sampling of their massive menu, but I would come back! I would also order custom cupcakes from here because I think my workplace did that once with our team logo and it was super cute.


If you go, which flavor did you like?


716 S Railroad Ave

San Mateo, CA 94401

18 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page